ALBUM REVIEW: Feeder - "Silent Cry"

First published: 2008-06-24

A version of this originally published at Orange.co.uk, for whom I'm now writing.

Necessity is the mother of invention, according to some ancient Greek bloke. So does the complete lack of invention shown on Silent Cry mean that the last thing the world really needs is another album from the band who bought us 'Buck Rogers'?

It'd be churlish to suggest that we've never needed the Welsh trio. Their early records helped fill a gaping Britrock void in the late 90s, and since 2001's Echo Park they've unleashed a handful of mini pop-classics that sit beautifully alongside 'Bohemian Like You' and 'Breakfast at Tiffany's on local radio stations across the land (admittedly, a back-handed compliment if ever there were one).

But the band's sixth record abandons that joyous melodic sensibility in favour of a faux-anthemic Snow Patrol approach. Opening track and lead single 'We Are The People' is a directionless dirge, produced, dubbed and layered to within an inch of its life to hide a chronic lack of what those in the music biz call 'bollocks'. And while 'Miss You' hints at Feeder's previous scratchy punk-pop brilliance, it's one of only a few moments of light relief in an album full of humourless attempts at mature radio ballads.

Silent Cry's 45 minutes are an overlong and tiring listen. At 13 tracks, it's like having to explain the same thing over and over to a stupid co-worker. And as the sort of intellectual giant who reads Plato-quoting record reviews in their spare time, surely you don't need music that reminds you of that feeling?