Techrights

KDE and Plasma Probably Won't be Wayland-Only

Posted by Roy Schestowitz on Nov 28, 2025,

updated Nov 28, 2025

Circular Financing in NVidia (NVidia Pays Its Clients to Buy From NVidia) and "Lessons From the Dotcom Crash"
Qwant Made a Partnership With Microsoft, It Already Regrets This and Has Filed Antitrust Complaint Against Microsoft

Based on false pretexts, some folks brainwash us into thinking Wayland is "inevitable" for KDE users. In reality, however, KDE stuff gets forked (KDE 3.5 is still alive) and many distros proved that systemd can be avoided if the developers are sufficiently eager. It'll be the same with Wayland.

false pretexts
folks brainwash us into thinking Wayland is "inevitable" for KDE users
↺ HTTP: gets forked (KDE 3.5 is still alive)
systemd can be avoided

KDE and Plasma users who rely on scripts/applications that don't support Wayland ought not worry; for many years to come X (or X11) will still be an option.

Wayland's wishful thinking and false prophecies go over a decade back.

"The Plasma Team" - a generic name which made the announcement - makes no disclosure/s about corporation/s or personal affiliation/s. This was its first and last blog post:

↺ HTTPS: "The Plasma Team"
HTTPS image: Only-ever blog post: The Plasma Team

This could just as well be IBM staff. In LWN, the following long comment stands out at the top:

↺ HTTPS: In LWN
I was not pleased when seeing the amount of errors in KDE 6.

KDE works with Wayland in a starting program - ending program - loop.

Not when using a lot of editors, shells, ... - where the workplace

is crucial ... like for professional workstations - or desktops.

I don't know whom to blame for the lack of features which

had been in CDE - but when no one needs professional features,

no one seems to work in a professional way any more.

But saving session should be one of the 1st things one would expect

to get working - I am not sure but I might read something about

this would be realized by Wayland protocols ... but not ready yet.

It seems a smartphone is all one needs to work in the digital world,

while no professional ever takes a smartphone seriously.

I hope KDE will get stable and I wish for a feature complete Wayland

experience - and like to work with it.

But security is just a bet - not a proven feature - and the lack of speed

when playing games show that a lot went wrong on the way to heaven.

I think dreaming or making perfect plans are not the way to achieve

a big technology win - except by marketing.

After 16+ years (as started in 2008) of Wayland development a lot

is lacking - and since years it was told that Wayland is ready ...

which I can not confirm - not at all.

And I can work with X11 why Wayland is not capable concerning my

workflow. Maybe any professional work with computers is about

to get illegal ... ;)

Otherwise, I don't think Wayland makes any sense in the current form.

A pletora of Wayland compositors show that there had been no clue in

the beginning and no real consolidation was done in all these years ...

so why are people still pretending Wayland is the future when it does not

even come near feature wise to the same level as CDE (started mid 1993

by Hewlett-Packard, IBM, SunSoft, and USL).

I think this is striking. And 'Wayback' should mean using X11 and not

trying to build on shattered ground.

We will see if that could ever be fixed ...

The immediate reply to that was sympathetic:

Anyhoo, with regards to having applications auto start, you the autostart config works and I've just listed the programs I want open. Sort of a manual session. Works well enough but of course it doesn't remember the desktop each program was on, and forget about Activity support. Admittedly, it has been a while since I've even tried session features in KDE Plasma... so I would love to be wrong and find out, silly me, they implemented already.
Now, having said all of that, I do not want to sound like a whiny, entitled person. Maybe it is too late. But I do indeed appreciate all of the hard work they do and have actually contributed funds a few times, but nowhere near as much as I should be given that I've been using KDE since 1998. I strongly encourage folks to donate to the project.

There are several more complaints further down the page, with some people (as usual) trying to blame applications rather than Wayland-related software with its shortcomings and inferior performance. █

HTTPS: █
gemini.techrights.org